What is Wrong with CCM? What is Wrong with Me?

Last night I participated in a panel at Seattle Pacific University (SPU) on the subject of popular music, with a particular focus on Contemporary Christian Music (CCM). Other panelists included Chad Johnson from “Tooth and Nail Records,” Benjamin Verdoes from “In Praise of Folly,” and Tara Ward from “Late Tuesday.”

I found myself particularly feisty in my negative comments about CCM and awoke this morning asking myself why. Three words came to mind.

1) Cocooning. CCM represents the “cocooning” I’ve spent most of my adult life trying to avoid. Anytime Christians set up a parallel universe to the “real world,” we are operating counter to Jesus who was sent into the world because of God’s love, spent his everyday life “in the world” at the parties & in the public square and then commanded his disciples to go into the world. CCM concerts & CCM stations regularly advertise themselves as “safe” places, by which they mean only “nice” is spoken here; we will not offend you. Parents are urged to encourage their kids to listen to CCM because their kids will avoid the “nasty” out there in the world. The music itself is described as inspirational and positive and in a great irony, the format is actually targeted at the 35 year-old house-wife not the kids! The more cynical among us could read all this as code for happy, silly Christians smiling goofily as if on a Disneyland ride. Like all seduction the cocooning model is a ‚½ truth. There is bad stuff out there in “the world,” parents ARE supposed to protect their kids while preparing for them for the real world, there is inspiration in the gospel, but like all ‚½ truths when you eat the fruit that looks good, like Eve, you may be surprised at the consequences.

2) Counterfeit. Counterfeit lyrical content and aesthetic is the byproduct of a musical format aimed at cocooning ourselves from the world instead of going into the world and preparing our kids to do the same. The one thing a true artist does is tell the truth and the one thing CCM assiduously avoids is telling the full truth about life, the human condition, our fallen-ness. When you aim for safe you arrive at a counterfeit gospel, for not only is the world not safe, neither is God. Remember in CS Lewis’ “Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe,” Lucy asks Mrs. Beaver is Aslan the Lion (Christ) is safe and Mr. Beaver replies, “Safe?” said Mr. Beaver. “Don’t you hear what Mrs. Beaver tells you?” “Who said anything about safe?” Course he isn’t safe. But he’s good. He’s the King I tell you.”

For those who know real life, any endeavor that says it is art & claims to represent the gospel, but wants to stay safe & inspirational, is a poser and will not ring true. If we fail to tell the truth about our human condition, which requires nastiness and messiness and is not all that inspirational, we will be unable to explore the riches and depth of the gospel which is about restoring ALL that unraveled in the Fall. That means Jesus wants to shine a light on every dirty, shameful little secret corner of YOUR life and mine and then begin the process of dealing with it. One thing “pagan” music is really good at is being honest about dirty, shameful secrets weird how it rings truer than inspirational pop huh? Annie Dillard got it right when she described today’s Christians as brainless tourists on a packaged trip to the “Absolute.” “On the whole I do not find Christians, outside the catacombs, sufficiently sensible of the conditions. Does anybody have the foggiest idea what sort of power we so blithely invoke? Or, as I suspect, does no one believe a word of it? The churches are children playing on the floor with their chemistry sets, mixing up a batch of TNT to kill a Sunday morning. It is madness to wear ladies’ straw hats and velvet hats to church; we should all be wearing crash helmets. Ushers should issue life preservers and signal flares; they should lash us to our pews. For the sleeping god may draw us out to where we can never return.”

3) Commercialism. As if cocooning and being a aesthetic and lyrical counterfeits aren’t bad enough, there are actually people who have the gall to make a lot of money off this scam. The 90’s saw the emergence of evangelicals as a political force, but when it comes to CCM what is really important is their emergence as a commercial force. Evangelicals, unencumbered by a radical gospel about sacrifically serving and loving others, and having replaced it with a gospel of personal, familial and professional success, have been freed to generate vast sums of money and then spend it on themselves and their kids; CCM is the beneficiary of this largesse. Busy working, unable to spend adequate time with their kids, parents want a safe place for their young ones and CCM, with its wholesome artists, simulated rock concerts and bubbly, chirpy syrupy local DJ’s playing anesthetizingly harmless music is just the place.

By now I hope you understand I’ve been describing a worse-case scenario for CCM. I know the other side of the story. Christians didn’t initially choose this cocoon, artists like Keith Green and Larry Norman got “pushed out” of mainstream and an alternative distribution stream was opened up for these legitimate artists who loved rock and roll and had just discovered Jesus. Artists who are Christian still have difficulty breaking into mainstream distribution channels. The music isn’t all lyrically and aesthetically bankrupt. Not everybody in CCM is getting rich and it is not TOTALLY driven by money, but it is a big business. And it is doing some good. Kids come to faith, grow in faith and are piloted through the life’s turmoil by the artists and music produced in CCM.

A lot of people in the CCM industry would agree with every concern I’ve raised and I raise them in the extreme, in part, to get the attention of Christians who aren’t thinking about faith and culture and the relationship between the two.

So I arose this morning armed with these three “C’s” (cocooning, counterfeit and commercialism), smug and satisfied with my rationalization about why I was so feisty and negative about CCM last night.

And then God showed up.

That is where the fourth C showed up and it wasn’t about CCM, it was about me. Conviction.

What I realized this morning is how absolutely prideful it is for ME to tell God what kind of tools can be used in shaping people. Last night one of the artists confessed that she had become a Christian through a “cheesy Christian novel.” She went on to say, “I hate those things.” It reminded me of Laura Winner who similarly was warmed to faith by a Jan Karon novel and bemoaned the fact that it wasn’t Dostoevsky or something literarily substantial that wooed her to God. A young man sincerely queried the panel about what we would say to him. He professed to be uninterested in the aesthetic of the “artistic” groups being promoted as lyrically and musically valid, and instead came to Jesus through the Praise and Worship scene.

Craig Detweiler talks about how some people are skeptical and then amazed that God is showing up and working through popular culture. Craig likens it to Balaam who is shocked when God speaks through his donkey. This is the way critics of CCM feel about CCM saying pejoratively, “well I guess of God can reach Balaam through his ass then he can reach people through CCM.”

Here is what God wanted me to understand. The truly amazing thing is that God could use me. I am free to state my concerns about the spiritually and aesthetically bankrupt faith and culture around me, so long as I don’t lose sight of the spiritual and aesthetic flaws WITHIN me. The truly amazing thing is not that God does not rise up and smite CCM. The truly amazing thing is that God does not rise up and smite me.

It is called God’s grace and understanding this makes a person humble. And not being humble is one thing I consistently do really well.

So we are back to GK Chesterton’s award winning essay. A newspaper invited submissions from readers regarding what is most wrong with the world and Chesterton’s essay was short, true and applicable for me today. Chesterton’s answer to what is wrong with the world?

“I am.”

Yours for the pursuit of God in the company of friends, Dick Staub.

PS. And remember, “these are the best of times and the worst of times, but they are the only times we have.” (For Now).

PS 2. If you haven’t yet done so, register for our daily updates. You won’t regret it!

  • Register for CW
  • PS 3.

    If you have comments regarding this column please contact us at:

  • CultureWatch: culturewatch@dickstaub.com

  • This web site is supported solely by tax-deductible donations. Please mail your generous contributions to: The Center for Faith and Culture, PO Box 77385, Seattle, Washington 98177

    ‚©CRS Communications 2005

    Posted in Staublog in April 6, 2005 by | No Comments »

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published.

    74 + = 80

    More from Staublog